Name not reported
A man held at the Erie County Holding Center in Buffalo died while in custody, and his family sued Erie County over his care for mental illness. His father told a jury that the two were far closer than most fathers and sons, constantly holding each other from his birth. A jury had awarded $9 million for loss of life, but the Appellate Division, Fourth Department, threw out that award, with Justice Ogden dissenting. The family's attorneys objected that the majority relied on a California judge's statement, which they say is not binding case law.
Cause of death, as reported: Died from neglect by staff (disputed). The Metcalf family's lawsuit says Erie County failed to provide adequate care for the man's mental illness while he was held at the Erie County Holding Center, and a jury awarded damages that the Appellate Division later threw out.
Reported by: Metcalf family, in a lawsuit against Erie County (family or their lawyers); Appellate Division, 4th Department (court).
Lawsuit: The Metcalf family sued Erie County over the man's care for mental illness, and a jury awarded $9 million for loss of life, but the Appellate Division, Fourth Department, threw out that award.