Deaths in CustodyWork in progressIn progress
New York

At least 4,021 people have died in custody in New York

1,330 of them are recorded here one by one, 1,261 by name. Another 2,691 are known only as numbers: deaths the official yearly counts report, for the same years, beyond the people recorded here.

At least 173 people have died in custody in New York so far in 2026. The most recent named here is Alberto Pena, who died on October 19, 2026 at Sing Sing Correctional Facility.

Each dot is one of them, held in a jail, prison or lockup, or executed by the state. Some died after abuse by officers; others from withdrawal, overdose or untreated illness; many by suicide. Almost all of them show the state’s neglect of the people in its custody.

This is an undercount: many deaths are never made public, and older records are hard to find.

Records go back as far as 1834 and are current as of October 28, 2026Get email alerts for New York

Their stories

0 people, most recent first. Choose a name, or a dot on the map.

    Their names

    When they died

    One mark per person, by the year they died. Choose the box at the side to see every decade. Coverage is uneven: recent deaths come mostly from local news since 2000, older ones from official lists and historical newspapers, so the shape shows what was recorded as much as how many people died.

    What death counts show

    Two sources count deaths in New York's state prisons each year, but not who died: the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics, as the state reported them to it, and, through 2020, researchers at UC Irvine, from the state's prison records, which they obtained through their own public records requests. Where both give a year, the larger count is shown. Most of those deaths, especially from illness, never appear in the news, so far fewer are recorded here. The gap is people still to be identified.

    The federal series ends in 2019, and the UC Irvine study in 2020; neither has been updated since.

    05010015020020012005201020152020100 reported34 recorded05010015020020012005201020152020100 reported34 recorded

    Sources: U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics, Mortality in State and Federal Prisons, 2001–2019; Excess Mortality in U.S. Prisons During the COVID-19 Pandemic (Sugie et al., 2023). Official counts are deaths in state prisons only; county jails report to no central agency.

    YearDeaths countedRecorded here
    2020100 UC Irvine34
    2019112 BJS27
    2018138 BJS16
    2017143 BJS4
    2016147 BJS9
    2015115 BJS9
    2014123 BJS4
    2013142 BJS6
    2012115 BJS1
    2011117 BJS0
    2010124 BJS3
    2009142 BJS0
    2008133 BJS1
    2007148 BJS0
    2006131 BJS0
    2005170 BJS0
    2004153 BJS0
    2003198 BJS1
    2002185 BJS0
    2001175 BJS1

    Where the most deaths are recorded

    The facilities in New York with the most deaths recorded here. Each has its own page, with everyone recorded as dying there; see all facilities.

    1. Mohawk Correctional Facility 86 deaths
    2. Wende Correctional Facility 72 deaths
    3. Coxsackie Correctional Facility 70 deaths
    4. Green Haven Correctional Facility 70 deaths
    5. Elmira Correctional Facility 52 deaths

    Where these records come from

    Each bar is a source and the years its records cover. Sources checked on a schedule are searched again for new records; the others were collected once.

    1. Historical newspapers1792–1934 · Searched once · Library of Congress digitized newspapers, searched for people taken from jails and officers and killed
      1792 to 1934
    2. Local news2000–today · Searched again every night · News coverage searched county by county and year by year
      2000 to today
    3. Official yearly counts (BJS)2001–2019 · Checked every month · Totals only; the agency does not publish names
      2001 to 2019
    4. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Detainee Death Reporting and List of Deaths in ICE Custody2011–2025 · Checked every week · From a list that covers 2003 to today
      2011 to 2025
    5. Yearly counts compiled by UC Irvine researchers2013–2020 · · Totals only, from state prison records (Sugie et al., Excess Mortality in U.S. Prisons, 2023)
      2013 to 2020
    6. New York State Commission of Correction, Medical Review Board, Incarcerated Mortality Reports2018–2025 · Checked every month · From a list that covers 2018 to today
      2018 to 2025
    7. 2019 to today
    8. 2021 to today
    9. 2025 to today
    10. 2025 to today
    11. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, news releases on deaths in its custody2025–2025 · Checked every few days · From a list that covers 2025 to today
      2025 to 2025

    What these deaths have cost taxpayers

    These deaths have cost taxpayers in New York at least $133 million: the amount governments have agreed or been ordered to pay the families and estates of at least 34 people recorded here, in settlements and court awards reported in the news, and private contractors at least $865,000 more. Families sued over at least 93 of these deaths. Many suits end with no amount made public, and many settlements are kept confidential, so the true cost is higher.

    PersonPaid byYearAmount
    John PriceNew York City (court award)$25 million
    Robert BrooksState of New York2026$24 million
    Richard Metcalf Jr.Erie County2024$20 million
    Terry L. CooperClinton Correctional Facility correction officers (court award)$9.3 million
    Juan Francisco Flores HidalgoNew York City (court award)$6.1 million
    Layleen Xtravaganza Cubilette-PolancoCity of New York2020$5.9 million
    Bradley BallardCity of New York2016$5.8 million
    Tarz YoungbloodNew York City$4 million
    India CummingsErie County$3.8 million
    Jason EchevarriaNew York City2015$3.8 million
    Rolando PerezCity of New York$3.5 million
    Kalief BrowderNew York City2019$3.3 million
    Ronald SpearNew York City2014$2.8 million
    Jose Mejia MartinezCity of New York$2.7 million
    Anthony ScottCity of New York$2.6 million
    Donny UbieraCity of New York$2.5 million
    Jerome MurdoughCity of New York$2.3 million
    Herman DiazNew York City$2.3 million
    Brandon RodriguezCity of New York$2.3 million
    Joseph FosterNew York City$2.1 million
    Christopher RobinsonNew York City2012$2 million
    Lonnie HamiltonState of New York (court award)$1.5 million
    Carlos MercadoCity of New York$1.5 million
    Angel RamirezNew York City$1.3 million
    Mark CannonAlbany County and Correctional Medical Care2017$1.1 million
    Angela PengOnondaga County and NaphCare$750,000
    Chanel LakatoszCorrect Care Solutions$440,000
    Chanel LakatoczOnondaga County2019$440,000
    Nicole CarmenCorrectional Medical Care$425,000
    Sitarah DanielsMonroe County$360,000
    Ayanna ByrdOnondaga County$100,000
    Nicole “Justy” MatkoskyChemung County$100,000
    LeslieAnn ManningState of New York2018$100,000
    Roberto GrantFederal Bureau of Prisons2022$75,000

    How deaths in custody are reported in New York

    New York Correction Law section 47 requires the administrator of every correctional facility in the state to report the death of an incarcerated person to the State Commission of Correction.1 The Commission's Medical Review Board investigates deaths in state prisons, county jails, New York City jails and police lockups, and posts redacted reports naming each person and the date of death.2 Not every death gets a report: in 2024, 181 deaths were reported to the Commission, which issued 61 investigation reports and closed 71 other cases administratively as natural or expected deaths.3

    The Department of Corrections and Community Supervision, which runs the state prisons, publishes a yearly mortality report counting deaths by prison and by manner of death, including deaths in outside hospitals.4 Since December 19, 2025, Correction Law section 624 has also required it to post a notice of each death on its website within 48 hours of telling the family.5 The notices give the person's name, date of birth, department identification number, date of death and the prison where they were housed, but no cause or place of death.6 Under County Law section 677, the county coroner or medical examiner decides whether an autopsy is released, and the department reports only the manner of death recorded in its unusual incident system.4

    Since April 1, 2021, Executive Law section 70-b has directed the Attorney General's Office of Special Investigation to investigate any death that a police or peace officer may have caused. Because correction officers in every jail and prison are peace officers, the office investigates or assesses every death in a state prison.7 Its data tables list each death it was notified of, with the person's name, age, race, gender, the agency involved and whether the person was incarcerated.8

    In New York City, the Department of Correction runs the jails on Rikers Island and in the boroughs. Local Law 105 of 2025 requires it to post a notice of each death, with the person's name, age, race, gender and facility, within 24 hours of notifying the family, and requires the Board of Correction to investigate deaths and post its reports.9 The Board publishes reports naming the people who died.10 For the federal Death in Custody Reporting Act, the Commission of Correction and the state prison department report deaths to the Division of Criminal Justice Services, which has no dedicated website for the data.1

    U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement publishes a report on each death in its custody.11 Its list for 2003 to 2017 includes Irene Bamenga, who died on July 27, 2011, while held in the Albany County Jail, and Santo Carela, who died on July 28, 2016, while held in the Orange County Jail.12 Santos Reyes Banegas died on September 18, 2025, while held for ICE at the Nassau County Correctional Center in East Meadow.13

    What has changed

    1. 1863On June 21, a mob broke through the doors of the Newburgh courthouse where Robert Mulliner was held, dragged him out and hanged him from a tree. Governor Kathy Hochul unveiled a state marker for him in 2022.14
    2. 1890On August 6, New York carried out the first execution by electric chair, of William Kemmler at Auburn State Prison. After the first current, witnesses saw him still breathing, and the switch was thrown again.15
    3. 1963New York carried out its last execution, of Eddie Mays. The state executed 1,130 people before 1976. A 1995 death penalty law was struck down in 2004, and by 2007 the state's death row was empty.15
    4. 1971On September 13, the New York State Police retook Attica Correctional Facility after a four-day uprising. Twenty-nine prisoners and nine hostages were killed by police gunfire; in all, 43 people died.1617
    5. 2019Layleen Xtravaganza Cubilette-Polanco, a 27-year-old Afro-Latinx transgender woman, died on June 7 in a punitive segregation unit on Rikers Island.10
    6. 2021On April 1, Executive Law section 70-b took effect, giving the Attorney General's Office of Special Investigation authority over deaths in every jail and prison.7
    7. 2024Robert Brooks, 43, was beaten by correction officers in the infirmary of Marcy Correctional Facility on December 9, and died of his injuries at a hospital in Utica. Their body cameras recorded the beating. Of the 10 people charged in his death, six pleaded guilty and a jury convicted one former officer of murder in October 2025.18
    8. 2025New York City enacted Local Law 105, requiring public notice of every death in city jails within 24 hours of notifying the family and Board of Correction investigations of deaths.9
    9. 2025From December 19, the state prison department began posting a notice of every death in its custody.5
    10. 2026On September 25, the Board of Correction released its first report on 2026 deaths in city custody, on the deaths of Barry Cozart, John Price, Rajpattie Ramkellawan and Umais Khan.10

    How far the official numbers can be trusted

    The prison department counts every death in its custody, including in outside hospitals: 137 deaths in 2021, 113 in 2022, 107 in 2023, 144 in 2024 and 130 in 2025.4 The manner of death in them is preliminary and changes as autopsy reports arrive, so each year's report revises earlier years. In the 2025 report, 15 of the year's deaths were still listed as unknown.4 Before 2020, overdoses were counted as accidents, and before 2024, undetermined deaths were counted as unknown.4

    The department's counts run slightly higher than those it reported to the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics, for example 113 against 112 for 2019, in records it released to the UCLA Law Behind Bars project.1920 Those records list 143 deaths for 2024, one fewer than the department's own 2025 report.194

    Jail deaths are harder to follow. The Commission of Correction investigates only some deaths and closes others without a report, and it cannot complete an investigation until it has the autopsy report and the Attorney General's office has reviewed the death. Its posted reports cover deaths from 2018 onward.32 New York City's open data set called "Inmate Deaths" is described as covering non-natural deaths, but its 22 records, from 2015 to 2024, are all suicides.21 In June 2023 the city's Department of Correction abruptly stopped notifying the public of deaths in its jails;22 Local Law 105 of 2025 made such notices mandatory.9

    Notes

    1. New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, "Death in Custody Reporting Implementation Plan," FY 2023 (U.S. Bureau of Justice Assistance copy). ↩
    2. New York State Commission of Correction, "Incarcerated Mortality Reports." ↩
    3. New York State Commission of Correction, "2024 Annual Report." ↩
    4. New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision, "Annual Mortality Report 2025." ↩
    5. New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision, "Incarcerated Deaths." ↩
    6. New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision, "2026 Incarcerated Deaths." ↩
    7. New York State Office of the Attorney General, Office of Special Investigation, "2026 Annual Report," October 1, 2026. ↩
    8. New York State Office of the Attorney General, Office of Special Investigation, data tables, April 1, 2021 to August 31, 2026. ↩
    9. New York City Local Law 105 of 2025, text (intro.nyc). ↩
    10. New York City Board of Correction, "Board of Correction Reports." ↩
    11. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, "Detainee Death Reporting." ↩
    12. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, "List of Deaths in ICE Custody, October 2003 - December 2017." ↩
    13. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, "Detainee Death Report: REYES Banegas, Santos." ↩
    14. Times Herald-Record (via Yahoo News), "Hochul unveils markers recognizing injustices to Black men lynched in Newburgh and Port Jervis," February 23, 2022. ↩
    15. Death Penalty Information Center, "New York." ↩
    16. Jeff Z. Klein, Buffalo Toronto Public Media, "Heritage Moments: The Attica Prison Uprising — 43 Dead and a Four-Decade Cover-Up." ↩
    17. New York State Police, "Attica Prison Riots." ↩
    18. Associated Press (via WSHU), "Guard found guilty in beating death of NY prisoner Robert Brooks, 2 others acquitted," October 20, 2025. ↩
    19. UCLA Law Behind Bars Data Project, New York state prison death records obtained from the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision (NY-Individual.csv). ↩
    20. U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics, "Mortality in State and Federal Prisons, 2001-2019 - Statistical Tables," December 2021, table 14. ↩
    21. NYC Open Data, "Inmate Deaths" (dataset f64t-5yiv). ↩
    22. The Legal Aid Society, "LAS Decries Abrupt End to Public Notifications of Deaths in Custody," June 2, 2023. ↩

    The 1,330 New York records here draw on 2,030 news reports from 366 outlets, mostly local newspapers and TV stations. Each person’s reports are listed with their story, so every detail can be traced to where it was published.

    How these records were made · See these records in a table

    Last updated October 28, 2026.