Carroll
Carroll was held in the Santa Rosa County jail in Florida, and on the night of July 10, 1875, newspapers of the time report that a mob was given access to the jail. The mob took him and lynched him. Only newspaper accounts of the time survive, which the coalition says are biased and cannot be fully verified.
Cause of death, as reported: Taken from custody and lynched (disputed). Newspapers of the time (Savannah Daily Advertiser, New Orleans Bulletin) report that a mob took Carroll from the Santa Rosa County prison and lynched him; the coalition says these accounts were biased and cannot be fully verified.
Reported by: Savannah Daily Advertiser (reporters); New Orleans Bulletin (reporters).